Study compares lie-telling behaviour in harshly punitive, mildly punitive environments
- Social Sciences - 06:00 2011 CENSUS: ethnic diversity is home grown
- Social Sciences - Jun 17 Moderate drinking during pregnancy does not appear to harm baby’s neurodevelopment
- Chemistry - Jun 17 ExoMars 2016 set to complete construction
- Medicine - Jun 17 Safety review of bone growth product ushers in new era of data sharing
- Astronomy - Jun 17 Herschel ends operations as orbiting testbed
- Medicine - Jun 17 The rhythm of everything
- Medicine - Jun 17 Changing how society thinks about senior citizens
- Astronomy - Jun 17 Final command: Herschel ends operations as orbiting testbed
- Life Sciences - Jun 17 British Academy recognition for Manchester professors
- Microtechnics - Jun 17 High- frequency trading tactic lowers investor profits
- Life Sciences - Jun 17 Strategy behind spiders’ web etiquette
- Administration - Jun 17 GOP Voters Favor Ted Cruz in 2016 Presidential Primary, UT/Texas Tribune Poll Shows
- Life Sciences - Jun 17 SDSC’s Gordon Supercomputer: Parsing Genes, Proteins, and Big Bio Data
- Medicine - Jun 17 Study Identifies Protein Essential for Normal Heart Function
- Life Sciences - Jun 17 First science star for Wales announced
- Medicine - Jun 17 Towards the ’holy grail’ of anticoagulant drugs
Harsh discipline fosters dishonesty in young children
Young children exposed to a harshly punitive school environment are more inclined to lie to conceal their misbehaviour than are children from non-punitive schools, a study of three- and four-year-old West African children suggests.
The study, published in the journal Child Development, also indicates that children in a punitive environment are able to tell more convincing lies than those in a non-punitive environment.
The research, by Professor Victoria Talwar of McGill University and Professor Kang Lee of the University of Toronto, examined deceptive behaviours in two groups of children living in the same neighbourhood. One group was enrolled in a private school that used a traditional authoritarian discipline model, in which beating with a stick, slapping of the head, and pinching were administered publicly and routinely for offenses ranging from forgetting a pencil to being disruptive in class. In the other school, also private, children were disciplined with time-outs or scolding and, for more serious offenses, were taken to the principal’s office for further reprimand.
The study involved an experiment comparing the behaviour of children in the two schools. Children were seen individually and asked to play a guessing game by an experimenter who was born and raised locally. The children were told not to peek at a toy when left alone in a room. Most children in both schools couldn’t resist the temptation, and peeked at the toy. When the experimenter asked if they had peeked, nearly all the peekers from the punitive school lied - compared with just over half of those from the non-punitive school. What’s more, after the initial lie, lie-tellers from the punitive school were better able to maintain their deception when answering follow-up questions about the identity of the toy - by deliberately giving an incorrect answer, for example, or by feigning ignorance, rather than blurting out the name of the toy.
The findings suggest that "a punitive environment not only fosters increased dishonesty but also children’s abilities to lie to conceal their transgressions," Talwar and Lee conclude.
In fact, the three- and four-year-old lie-tellers in the punitive school were as advanced in their ability to tell convincing lies as six- to seven-year-old lie-tellers in existing studies. "This finding is surprising," the authors note, as "existing studies have consistently found that children from punitive environments tend to suffer general delays in cognitive development."
"One possibility is that the harsh punitive environment heightens children’s motivation to come up with any strategies that will help them survive in that environment," Lee says. "Lying seems particularly adaptive for the situation.
"Our study, I think, may serve as a cautionary tale for parents who sometimes would use the harshest means of punishment when they catch their children lying. It is clear that corporal punishment not only does not reduce children’s tendency to lie, but actually improves their lying skills."
Last job offers
- Civil Engineering - 18.6
Wissenschaftliche/r Mitarbeiter/in Nachhaltiges Bauen (60 - 80 %)
- Psychology - 17.6
Wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin / Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter
- Medicine - 17.6
Research Scientist (Musculoskeletal Regeneration Program)
- Microtechnics - 15.6
Wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin / wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter (80-100%)
- Pedagogy - 14.6
Collaborateur ou Collaboratrice scientifique (80%)
- Law - 13.6
Zwei Wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiter / innen (50-80%)
- Medicine - 17.6
Associate Professorship in Medical Psychology
- Medicine - 16.6
Associate Professor / professor of Rehabilitation Studies (psychosocial Health)
- Earth Sciences - 17.6
Professur für „Archäometrie“
- Pedagogy - 14.6
Professur für Realschulpädagogik und - didaktik
- Law - 17.6
Associate Professor in Law
- Mechanical Engineering - 17.6
Lecturer (Assistant Professor) in Civil Engineering
- Business - 15.6
Assistant / Associate/Professor of Marketing
- Media Sciences - 15.6
Assistant Professor - Contractually Limited Appointment