Honesty may be the best policy, but new research from the University of Sydney suggests that consumers feel more satisfied if they lie and get what they want than if they tell the truth.
- Medicine - Jun 18 More help needed for nerve damage sufferers
- Careers - Jun 18 U.S. economy: Steady as she goes
- Medicine - Jun 18 Timely treatment after stroke is crucial, UCLA researchers report
- Life Sciences - Jun 18 FACULTY HONOR: Bassler elected associate member of European Molecular Biology Organization
- Astronomy - Jun 18 The fast winds of Venus are getting faster
- Astronomy - Jun 18 Scripps Alumna Selected as a NASA Astronaut Candidate
- Medicine - Jun 18 Fantastic four win Queen’s Birthday Honours
- Environmental Sciences - Jun 18 U-M researcher and colleagues predict possible record- setting Gulf of Mexico ’dead zone’
- Medicine - Jun 18 School of Nursing clinic fights spread of TB on L.A.’s skid row
- Careers - Jun 18 New project aims to get stroke survivors in Nottingham back to work
- Microtechnics - Jun 18 Engineering the Future
- Earth Sciences - Jun 18 Ground monitoring equipment is deployed on two Ethiopian volcanoes showing signs of unrest
- Literature - Jun 18 The verdict on tiger- parenting? Studies point to poor mental health
- Medicine - Jun 18 Women in childbirth still being denied their human rights
- Life Sciences - Jun 18 Centre reveals the wonder of genetic research to public
The study, to be published in the Journal of Consumer Research by Christina Anthony and Professor Elizabeth Cowley of the University of Sydney Business School , found that people who lie during a service encounter have more extreme reactions to the outcome than their honest peers.
The research raises interesting questions about the way marketers and businesses respond to dishonest customers and train their staff, particularly given the volume of lies people tell every day - previous research shows that people tell on average one to two lies a day, which equates to about 42,000 lies before the age of 60.
"Lying is hard work. When people lie, they’re so preoccupied with telling the lie and not revealing the truth that they aren’t able to monitor cues from the listener, which are important for updating expectations about the likely outcome of the conversation. This means that they are more surprised by the outcome and so have a stronger reaction to it," says Anthony.
"So when you lie to get a refund or to file an insurance claim and get away with it, you will have a much more polarised reaction than if you had told the truth. People who lie are more satisfied than truth tellers if they get a favourable outcome and more dissatisfied if they get an unfavourable outcome."
The researchers conducted a series of lab experiments in which participants either told the truth or lied during a conversation with a service provider in order to get a material reward. This included lying to a salesperson about better competitor offers to secure a more favourable deal and lying to obtain a refund that fell outside the terms of the refund policy.
In one experiment, participants were asked to answer some questions about a consumer product and told that some of them would receive the product as a prize if they met some pre-determined criteria. Half of the participants were then informed that they were eligible for the prize, even though their responses did not match the specified eligibility criteria - and they knew it. Participants therefore had a choice: to lie and get the prize, or to correct the error and miss out.
"We found that about 50 percent of participants in this situation chose to lie. They were more thrilled with the outcome when they got the prize and more disappointed when they missed out," says Anthony.
The fact that customers who lie have more extreme reactions to service encounters also has important consequences for businesses and marketers, says Anthony.
"Because a successful lie may boost satisfaction with a transaction, it may be wise in some instances to turn a blind eye if the company doesn’t have too much to lose financially."
"If marketers are overly cautious of dishonest consumers, they also run the risk of wrongly accusing and alienating people who are telling the truth."
Last job offers
- Social Sciences - 19.6
wissenschaftliche/r Assistent/in - (75 - 100 %)
- Civil Engineering - 18.6
Wissenschaftliche/r Mitarbeiter/in Nachhaltiges Bauen (60 - 80 %)
- Psychology - 17.6
Wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin / Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter
- Medicine - 17.6
Research Scientist (Musculoskeletal Regeneration Program)
- Microtechnics - 15.6
Wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin / wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter (80-100%)
- Pedagogy - 14.6
Collaborateur ou Collaboratrice scientifique (80%)
- Physics - 18.6
Professor i fysik
- Pedagogy - 18.6
Professor in Economics, with a specialisation in labour economics
- Business - 18.6
Professur für Allgemeine Betriebswirtschaftslehre, insbesondere, Finanzintermediation
- Social Sciences - 18.6
Juniorprofessur für Internationale Organisationen (W1)
- Interdisciplinary - 18.6
Professor in Interdisciplinary Social Science
- Civil Engineering - 18.6
Associate Professor in Urban Studies (Urban Informatics/Data Visualization)
- Social Sciences - 19.6
Visiting Assistant Professor - School of Social Work and Business Administration (F1300045)
- Media Sciences - 18.6
Political Science - Assistant or Associate Professor (AA3475)